
As kids we all dream of being larger than life heroes, especially our favorite heroes, or at least sharing their abilities and talents. This is true no matter what medium your heroes come from. Unless you’re Fredric Wertham, M.D., then it only makes sense if it comes from a book. One of the reasons I bring some of the villains of books is because Wertham doesn’t understand, or care to understand, comics as a medium. He didn’t grow up with them so they are wrong, even though books give you the same characters and alleged lessons that comics do. They just take longer to read so you have more exposure to the likes of Captain Ahab, Long John Silver, or Count Dracula.
It’s Wertham’s inability to accept and work with this new medium that is troubling, but if the kids are only reading bits and pieces while looking at the pictures they are reading the comics wrong. And if Wertham were honest about this he would try to see what the stories are actually trying to show and convince these troubled kids they are taking the lesson wrong, which can happen with everything from books to the nightly news. He is not honest about comics because he is biased against them not only as a therapist but as a reader who holds his favored medium in such a high regard that he will not allow anything else to even have a spot. I have read books since I was a kid. I have read comics since I was a kid, and I love both. Wertham doesn’t believe that’s possible, which makes them a good scapegoat for kids doing bad things. Influence is one thing but there is a read we are drawn to different stories or images while others, including other kids as we’ve seen, are repulsed by them. So how does this affect the heroes these kids seek to emulate?
Don’t forget to read this section yourself first if you haven’t already. After all, we’re all about reading here.
Continue reading →
Tell others about the Spotlight: