One of the more childish pushbacks by modern Hollywood creators is that you can’t really critique them because you don’t create anything yourself, because only the opinion of their entertainment peers matters to them. “You can’t possibly know what goes into making the things we do so you can’t properly judge my works.” This is bullcrap. I don’t need to be an artist to know I don’t like the art, and don’t have to be a writer to know I don’t enjoy the story. Before I became either of those things I was a fan, and fans know what they like and don’t like, and vote accordingly with their time and wallets.
So what happens when a critic actually makes something? Will their opinion matter now or will there be a new way to ignore any negative critique? Will Jordan can now claim to find out. He’s written a novel series featuring CIA secret operative Ryan Drake, and he’s also made and co-wrote a pilot, or a “proof of concept” as he calls it, for a TV series (or possibly streaming series) starring the character he created, titled Rogue Elements.
He’s also known online as The Critical Drinker, scourge of the current Hollywood culture. I’ve used a few of his videos for the Daily Video or occasional filler, so let’s see what happens when he puts his words into action.
In this crowdfunded pilot, Drake and his team have to extract a captured informant who has information that could stop the Russians taking back control of parts of Eastern Europe, the former USSR. However, it’s also personal as the Russian agent who took him also tortured and killed one of his friends…and he’s not the only one out for revenge. For readers of the books, and I have not had the opportunity, the short film takes place between the second and third books in Jordan’s “Ryan Drake” series. Perhaps you can also tell me why Drake doesn’t sound American and what the deal is with the blond lady. (No spoilers in the intro.) This has all the violence and language of an R rated movie, so heads up on that. If you’re okay with that, enjoy.
Continuity Vs Anthology
The Literature Devil showed this clip on Wednesday’s Morning Nonsense stream, and that got my waking brain going.
The above clip and corresponding tweets on X-Twitter (hopefully it’s coming up for you since the rebrand has messed with embeds) features James Gunn basically stating that because story is fiction canon is “whatever you want it to be”. Remember, this is the guy creating an entire universe, has had trouble deciding whether or not his DC movies and shows will or won’t be canon to the new movie continuity (they’re his so of course they are, even recently stating they’ll be using the recon bomb to force season one of Peacemaker into the new Gunniverse of movies and animated series to explain the Snyder Justice League cameo), and will be in charge of this universe going forward. He does not believe in a set canon according to that clip. I don’t know what podcast is from so I can’t confirm the context, but if accurate this does not bode well for Warner Brothers’ latest attempt to challenge Disney on the superhero front as the new DC Studios seeks to go head to head with Marvel Studios, who have themselves ditched respecting the comics like they did with the MCU first began and Paramount was doing the distribution.
There are times I’m worried the horse is so beaten that the glue factory can’t work with the remains, but then some necromancer pops up and restores the horse. The debate over canon has more resurrections than Optimus Prime at this point, as many writers out there are more interested in stories than continuity. Canon is the cohesion of a continuity for a series or a shared universe. That’s not what they want to make, though. What they’re really asking for isn’t a shared or even ongoing universe, but an anthology, something more akin to The Twilight Zone or even Golden Age comics than what a series or franchise is supposed to be. Marvel Studios is forgetting that, DC Studios seems poised to never learn that lesson, and both of the comics that spawned the movie studios that spurn their parent media are losing the ability to do this as well. Stories do not a series make. I think we need to learn the difference.
Continue reading →
Tell others about the Spotlight:
Posted by ShadowWing Tronix on November 29, 2024 in Book Spotlight, Comic Spotlight, Movie Spotlight, Television Spotlight and tagged canon, commentary, continuity, debate.
1 Comment