
“How can you call yourself a fan of Star Wars if you don’t like this?”
Ah, the old fan debate. How can you call yourself a fan of this or that franchise if you don’t like everything that comes from that franchise? This was the cry of the fan who liked everything that had the name attached to it. Slap Star Wars on a pencil case and they want it to “support the franchise”. The game is terrible, but we never expected our favorite show or comic to have a video game so you have to love it. Oddly, Superman fans don’t say this about any Superman game, especially Superman 64. It’s like they’re so worried that we’ll never get another one because the company will think it’s the brand that’s not popular and not the crappy game or side story that there won’t be another one.
Recently years another group has found a way to use this stupid argument to support their cause, the corporate overlords. I used Star Wars as my example because this “argument” by DisneyFilm and their willing accomplices in the shill media have used this as their rallying cry, which was brought up in a discussion on the Morning Nonsense podcast and the example was boosted by the Just Some Guy video I posted earlier today and other videos on the latest hit to the IP, The Acolyte. If you don’t like this show then you aren’t a “true fan” of Star Wars, and you probably only hate it because you’re a racistsexisthomophobe. You aren’t happy with women in Star Wars, despite all the women in Star Wars under the George Lucas era and “wilderness years” movies, shows, comics, novels, and games both in an out of canon. LucasFilm didn’t always make the best stories and characters. Jar-Jar Binks isn’t being given a second chance even though the prequels are for not being the sequels or the “High Republic” periods. The claim is that you have to like it because it’s Star Wars. The name is right there, so you must love it…except for Jar-Jar, but today’s defenders will include the High Republic. The only High Republic stories that at all interested me was Young Jedi Adventures, and it’s hardly going to fit into canon. Not too many lesbian moms are going to let their daughter fly around the universe with her Padawan youngling friends in her own non-Falcon starship.
What is in a name? A Rose Tico by any other name would still be a lousy character, even if it was a straight white male. We’re supposed to believe it was due to anger against an Asian woman and that they chased Kelly Marie Tran off (pre X) Twitter despite her own declarations to the contrary. Does simply having the name mean you have to like it, or is the bigger picture being missed here, like why were fans so in love with the brand but aren’t now? Is it the brand, or is it the reason the brand became so popular that the usual suspects wanted it because it was popular, or as they’re referred to here at BW, the everything for meeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee crowd.
Continue reading →
Tell others about the Spotlight:
Brand Loyalty Vs Fan Loyalty
“How can you call yourself a fan of Star Wars if you don’t like this?”
Ah, the old fan debate. How can you call yourself a fan of this or that franchise if you don’t like everything that comes from that franchise? This was the cry of the fan who liked everything that had the name attached to it. Slap Star Wars on a pencil case and they want it to “support the franchise”. The game is terrible, but we never expected our favorite show or comic to have a video game so you have to love it. Oddly, Superman fans don’t say this about any Superman game, especially Superman 64. It’s like they’re so worried that we’ll never get another one because the company will think it’s the brand that’s not popular and not the crappy game or side story that there won’t be another one.
Recently years another group has found a way to use this stupid argument to support their cause, the corporate overlords. I used Star Wars as my example because this “argument” by DisneyFilm and their willing accomplices in the shill media have used this as their rallying cry, which was brought up in a discussion on the Morning Nonsense podcast and the example was boosted by the Just Some Guy video I posted earlier today and other videos on the latest hit to the IP, The Acolyte. If you don’t like this show then you aren’t a “true fan” of Star Wars, and you probably only hate it because you’re a racistsexisthomophobe. You aren’t happy with women in Star Wars, despite all the women in Star Wars under the George Lucas era and “wilderness years” movies, shows, comics, novels, and games both in an out of canon. LucasFilm didn’t always make the best stories and characters. Jar-Jar Binks isn’t being given a second chance even though the prequels are for not being the sequels or the “High Republic” periods. The claim is that you have to like it because it’s Star Wars. The name is right there, so you must love it…except for Jar-Jar, but today’s defenders will include the High Republic. The only High Republic stories that at all interested me was Young Jedi Adventures, and it’s hardly going to fit into canon. Not too many lesbian moms are going to let their daughter fly around the universe with her Padawan youngling friends in her own non-Falcon starship.
What is in a name? A Rose Tico by any other name would still be a lousy character, even if it was a straight white male. We’re supposed to believe it was due to anger against an Asian woman and that they chased Kelly Marie Tran off (pre X) Twitter despite her own declarations to the contrary. Does simply having the name mean you have to like it, or is the bigger picture being missed here, like why were fans so in love with the brand but aren’t now? Is it the brand, or is it the reason the brand became so popular that the usual suspects wanted it because it was popular, or as they’re referred to here at BW, the everything for meeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee crowd.
Continue reading →
Tell others about the Spotlight:
Posted by ShadowWing Tronix on June 11, 2024 in Animation Spotlight, Book Spotlight, Comic Spotlight, Movie Spotlight, Television Spotlight, Video Game Spotlight, web series and tagged commentary, fan, Fan (person), Star Wars, theory.
1 Comment