The internet was all abuzz when the news of Lian Harper died in Cry For Justice. Up until that point, the series was referred to as “Cry for Boredom”, because besides characters complaining about wanting “justice” and an allusion to Hal Jordan (current co-Messiah with Barry Allen in the DC Universe) having a threesome with the Huntress and Lady Blackhawk, not much happened.

Then came issue 5, where Roy Harper’s arm gets ripped off, and #6, where we learn it was a supervillain named Prometheus. In #7, Prometheus’ master plan is enacted and Star City is blown up, and Lian with it. Suddenly we went from boring to what the hell are you thinking! If DC’s powers that be (who now be more powerful) happily greenlit this, among all the rest of the post-Infinite Crisis stories, why should I stay around to care about this universe?

But there’s one point I think has been lost in the fan rage against the unnecessary (note that word) death of an 8-year-old girl. The supporting cast has been slowly wiped out for a long time now.

And of course, the subject of Donna's dead baby was handled with all the class DC can muster.

This problem has existed long before IC, though. The DC honchos have been tearing the supporting cast away for a while, either writing them out, turning them evil, or just bumping them off. They’ll be the victim of character assassination in order to cover a hero’s mistakes (allegedly) in the eyes of the reader, thus being a cop-out. So far, only the Superman cast has gotten through mostly unscathed. Cat Grant had her child killed by Toyman a malfunctioning Toyman robot (apparently supervillains can rape superheroes’ spoused but not kill children unless mass destruction is involved). Oh, and Cat’s character growth was undone, as she reverted to something akin to her portrayal in Lois & Clark and acting as the “J. Jonah Jameson” to Supergirl’s “Spider-Man”. That’s the backsliding timeline.

The backsliding timeline: That’s where a new writer/editor comes along and wants to push everything back so THEY can tell “that story” with “those characters”. It’s why the Spider-Marriage was undone and Tony Stark uploaded his brain like a Windows repair. It’s why Hal, Ollie, and Barry are back, and their replacements are either altered, reverted, or just killed off. One observer noted that the potential “next generation” of heroes are being shoved aside (see also Teen Titans Bloodbath Dance Party). Lian could have been a future Red/Green Arrow, and one fancomic she was.

Note that the CCA only requested we not see the body.

This is the reason I never picked up Green Lantern as a series. (image source: DC Database)

But when was the last time you saw superheroes having some downtime with their friends and family? Holiday special? Clark and Lois aren’t even on the same planet lately. Batman, before he died, all but chased off his “Batman Family” sometime ago because the writers/editors thought that he should be a brooding loner, Barry came back to find his history changed so that his mom was killed by his father when he was a kid (despite that the Allens were alive and well after he died) so he could be a “better hero”. Which takes me back to Alex and what I call the “Batman complex”.

There seems to be a thought that to make a character a “real hero” there needs to be some big tragedy. That’s Batman’s origin story, and a few other characters (Punisher and Spider-Man over at Marvel, for example), but everyone is getting this lately. Pa Kent was killed during a Braniac attack, Kara’s dad was killed, and before being killed himself (he recently got better because Didio and Johns like him), Superboy also lost a loved one.

Death is meaningless in the DC Universe now, just a plot device used as “shock value” to draw in readers or as a source of tragedy to create a “better hero” or explore the fact that death is a part of the crimefighting game, regardless of the lost potential of the character.

She's a better character alive than dead!

Which brings this article full circle back to little Lian. So sweet, innocent, and cute, Lian could brighten up a moment and add a cute moment that makes you go “awwww”, not to mention watching Roy handle being a father and a superhero. But as with the Spider-Marriage and the writing out of Baby May, superheroes having family and friends tend to be few and far between. The writers and editors seem to forget that it’s THESE moments with loved ones who aren’t a part of the “mask” side of the hero (even when they know about the dual identity) that helps us to connect with the hero, learn their motivations, and make them feel human.

For all the arguments that they want to bring “realism” to comics, what is more real than that?

In part 3: The final rant in this set has me looking at one of the defender’s arguments: “why should Lian survive the destruction of Star City when so many other kids and adults must have died”. Beyond the fact that she’s a semi-main character, let me ask a different question: “why did they have to destroy Star City in the first place?” Not that other fictional cities in the DC Universe haven’t suffered as well.

About ShadowWing Tronix

A would be comic writer looking to organize his living space as well as his thoughts. So I have a blog for each goal. :)

4 responses »

  1. The death of Lian didn’t even make sense from a dramatic standpoint. She hadn’t even appeared in the series up to that point, and had been mentioned in an off-hand way only once. Assuming that you do want the death of a character to be the big emotional lynchpin of your mini-series, shouldn’t the character actually BE in the mini-series? It was just so completely random…


    • ShadowWing Tronix says:

      From what I hear, Roy wasn’t really in the series until his arm was ripped off by not-Freddy. I and many others I’ve seen comments from have said that if her death served a decent purpose, it might not be so bad. But it only existed for shock value and to mess with the Arrows.

      I saw in the previews for Green Arrow’s upcoming mini-series that Lian’s body appears to be in worse shape than in Cry For Justice, and that scene wasn’t as emotional as it could have been.


  2. Dee says:

    Great article
    The death rate in the DCU has been a major turn off for me as a fan, it was one of the reasons I quit reading comics was because they became a gore fest and not a fun read.
    Recently and quit stupidly I lurked and found out about Lian and all I could think was that’s a new low.

    This sort of storytelling is juvenile at best callous and cruel at worst and it speaks very ill of the writers and editors.
    I’ll never forget the quote by the late great Mark Gruenwald “Every Character is somebody’s favorite you shouldn’t kill them off lightly or worse ruin their appearances in retrospect.” Because it is the truth, and nothing but. Your childhood is gone however I think you can write in the spirit of it using the cast of today.

    and to the people who say that why should Lian had lived when so many had died
    well it is to show is that there is hope in the darkness, that when the worst happens to a city so do miracles and that reminds us that there is hope.


  3. […] or eliminate a perfectly good character. Longtime readers remember when I went over the case of Lian Harper,  a little girl who was the daughter of Roy Harper, single father and superhero. She was killed […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s