Transformers The Movie #3

“Do you mind? I’m trying to eat here.”

Actually, should they have revealed Unicron on the cover?

Transformers: The Movie #3

FINAL ISSUE

Marvel Comics (February, 1987)

“The Final Battle!”
ADAPTATION: Ralph Macchio
PENCILER: Don Perlin
INKERS: Ian Akin & Brian Garvey
COLORIST: Nel Yomtov
LETTERER: Janice Chaing
EDITOR: Bob Budiansky

There actually aren’t a lot of changes from the movie in this one. The scenes on Junkion play out like they should with two notable exceptions. The biggest one I actually know why they changed. Originally Ultra Magnus was supposed to be drawn and quartered by the Sweeps, as reflected in the comic. However, someone thought that looked too gruesome for a kids movie…and Prowl’s smoking from the inside near the beginning of the movie was just fine? They also took out the battle between the surviving Autobots and the Junkions before the others arrived in the Quintesson ship but that was probably for time. Also, Daniel’s exo-suit (which used to be Spike’s even though he was older than Daniel when he first met the Autobots) is red and blue. Why Nel Yomtov of all people, who uses blue shadow later on Bumblebee and miscolors Cliffjumper, would give himself more work with Daniel’s exo-suit I can’t imagine.

Speaking of Daniel, his whole scene rescuing Spike, Bumblebee, Jazz, and Cliffjumper is removed from the adaptation. This was the whole reason having Daniel in the story, so the kids could see one of their own get to be a hero, but without it he’s entirely pointless to the story. He could have been written out of the comic adaptation and not affect the story. IDW was right to give the adaptation four issues instead of three, and remember these are the guys who only gave three comics to the adaptation of Star Trek II: The Wrath Of Khan, which really hurt that one in the end.

Another thing hurt is Hot Rod’s transformation into Rodimus Prime. No, this isn’t my usual dislike of Rodimus in play. The adaptation really doesn’t give us the build-up. The scene with Hot Rod saving Kup on Quintessa was removed last issue, the foreshadowing glow from Optimus’ death scene was removed from the first issue, and anything that shows Hot Rod’s inner leadership qualities are removed, losing the full effect when he finally grabs the wrongly-drawn Matrix (which does match the early design, and for some reason in this issue only keeps getting called the Leadership Matrix instead of Matrix of Leadership, and if you’ve seen the show the word switch is noticeable) and becomes Rodimus it comes out of nowhere.

If you really need an adaptation of Transformers: The Movie (although the DVD is easy to find–granted Amazon has it rather expensive new but there are other avenues) I think you’re better off tracking down the IDW adaptation–sadly the only time they let Budiansky write a Transformers comic. It’s a lot better and closer to the final product. I’d only hunt this version as a curiosity.

[UPDATED ADDITION: That means the next two weeks will look at the IDW version of the finale. Like I said here, this version is only interesting for the minor changes between the earlier script and the final animation. The art looks like the other Transformers comics Marvel was producing at the time, Hot Rod’s journey to becoming Rodimus Prime as well as Daniel’s whole purpose was removed, and it’s just not as good an adaptation as it could have been. Hopefully IDW’s is better. We’ll see over the next two weeks]

Advertisements

About ShadowWing Tronix

A would be comic writer looking to organize his living space as well as his thoughts. So I have a blog for each goal. :)

One response »

  1. Sean says:

    I’m so glad that I bought my DVD copy of the Transformers Movie in 2008 when prices were reasonable. It truly is amazing how bad inflation is with some DVDs on Amazon. For instance, have you seen what the prices are of some Doctor Who DVDs on there???? I was shocked by some prices quoted for Doctor Who: The Time Meddler DVD when I looked that up in the past on Amazon. For now, I’ll just stick to my Time Meddler novel, thank you very much. It was so well written, that I could actually picture the Vikings and the Saxons along with the natural setting of northern England at that time period of 1066 A.D.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s