BW’s Daily Christmas Video: Christmas Stereotypes

Catch more Dude Perfect on their YouTube channel.

Scanning My Collection: Robotech Special

By now we know the history. Super Dimension Fortress Macross was chosen by Harmony Gold to be dubbed and edited for Western television, but it had too many episodes for a weekend run and too few for a weekday run. So two other shows were chosen, they licensed the name “Robotech” from Revell, who was making Macross model kits under that name in the US, and a series was born. The second war comes from the unconnected Super Dimension Calvary Southern Cross, which became known as Robotech Masters in the recent remaster (where all the nudity and blood were put back in but otherwise uses the same audio from the original show with a new intro that uses the same theme song) because that’s what Comico named that series. But why were all three wars given different names?

In total 85 episodes of Robotech came from the three wars (Genesis Climber Mospedia became the third Robotech War/Robotech: The New Generation). Comico The Comic Company (the publisher’s full name at the time, like “Marvel Comics Group”) published their comics either monthly or bimonthly. Already the comic lasted on shelves longer than the show aired on television by splitting the three wars into their own series. Imagine how long it would have taken to publish an 85 issue series on a monthly basis. This was actually a good idea on Comico’s part. However it led to a problem.

The first episode of the Masters saga is “Dana’s Story”, a clip show meant to bridge the gap between the first and second war, and allows Dana to tell her parents backstory. Dana Sterling is of course the daughter of Max and Miriya Sterling, but since the two shows are separate from each other this connection was one of the ways show creator Carl Macek tried to turn three disconnected shows into one complete story. The problem is that this episode basically spoils the wedding of a human and Zentraedi long before either character showed up in the comics. So the first issue of Robotech Masters is the second episode of the show. This kind of works as “Dana’s Story” doesn’t have a counterpart in Southern Cross. It was culled together from clips of the both shows to form an original introduction mainly of Dana and her best friend Bowie Grant, the two most important characters in this part of the story. So after the Masters comic ended this comic was produced to complete the collection and give us not only a proper adaptation of “Dana’s Story”, but as the writer would do with his run on the Robotech comics attempt to build on the episode and flesh things out. When it comes to this adaptation there are some minor changes but there are plenty of additions.

I didn’t think streaming sites ran on computers that old.

Robotech Special

Comico The Comic Company (May, 1998)

“Dana’s Story”

ADAPTATION: Markālan Joplin

ARTISTS: Thomas A. Tenney & Mike Chen

COLORIST: Tom Reilly

COVER: Ken Steacy (with thanks to Vic and Barb–the full cover shows more of the room and indicates this could be Dana’s room or just a really huge Robotech fan)

LETTERER: Bob Pinaha

EDITORS: Maggie Brenner & Diana Schutz

Continue reading →

“Yesterday’s” Comic> Robotech: The Misfits

They may not be the best soldiers, but I hear their songs are better.

Robotech: Misfits

Academy Comics, Ltd (August, 1996)

WRITER: Robert W. Gibson

ARTIST: Ryan Shelley

Continue reading →

Explaining TheOdd1sOut To A Non-Fan (by a different non-fan)

A sample of the comic that led to the web series. Clicking leads to the full strip.

Let me clarify that title before I move on. I have nothing against James Rallison’s comic or video work, nor am I hear to directly talk about said work. This isn’t a review, it’s a response…just one that doesn’t feel harsh enough to give it the BW Vs. title. I did try to watch some of his “storytime” videos but for whatever reason it didn’t grab me the same way Jaden Animations or Let Me Explain Studios did, and I only have so much watch time, as my huge YouTube backlog would easily demonstrate. Heck, given my uncoolness the fact I even know about him says something as there are a lot of YouTube celebrities I’ve never heard of or only heard of in someone else’s video. I do three articles a day and a weekly comic, and nap a lot lately so you’ll forgive me if I don’t subscribe to everyone, and even people I subscribe to I occasionally pass on an episode if only to get some control in that backlog. Obviously he does good work and is good friends with Jaden but I didn’t make that connection. I’m sure he doesn’t miss my viewership given how popular he is and he has earned his success.

This leads in to a recent article by Rob Salkowitz over at ICv2 sparked an interesting thought process. It seems like every time he gets mentioned on this site it’s me responding to something I disagree with but I have used him for Article Link posts as well, and as things go this is kind of mild. I’ve seen far harsher critiques before and after the video I posted this morning on YouTube’s animation enthusiasts in general and TheOdd1sOut specifically I wondered about his own comments about Rallison’s work. For those of you who missed the video Rallison started the TheOdd1sOut webcomic, struggled to work on it, changed to a more minimal art style with the characters, and gained huge success as a comic creator and an animator. While the comic archive seems to stop at 2017 his videos have continued on, and I though Salkowitz represented a mindset of those who can’t accept the new way comics are created, or at least was a bit harsh to Rallison’s work. Allow me to demonstrate and note I’m not railing against Salkowitz either. I have little experience with this myself but I know a bit more and wanted to comment. Also I needed something to talk about tonight and this won.

Continue reading →

“Yesterday’s” Comic> Star Trek: Starfleet Academy #1

“Are you sure we’re aiming right?” “Well, I saw the Avengers do this yesterday.”

Star Trek: Starfleet Academy #1

Marvel/Paramount Comics (December, 1996)

“Prime Directives”

WRITER: Chris Cooper

PENCILER: Chris Renaud

INKER: Andy Lanning

COLORIST: Kevin Somers

LETTERER: Jim Novak

EDITOR: Bobbie Chase

Continue reading →

BW’s Daily Videos: History Of YouTube Animators

And because it factors into tonight’s post…

Admittedly I don’t watch Odd1sOut but I did learn about Jaden Animations through that first video and I do enjoy her and Let Me Explain Studios. I don’t have time to watch everyone on YouTube, you know. Also, check out more Footofaferret/Ryder on his YouTube channel.

Why Adaptations Fail

Adapting a book to a movie or TV series is a difficult climb. What a book can do and what a movie can do (and what they can’t do) are very different and some alterations are to be expected. Audiobooks are a bit easier since its just someone reading a book. Meanwhile video game adaptations and adaptations of video games have their own issues. Adapting is hard, but has resulted in some great stories in a fresh style.

The following video from Center Row on YouTube goes over the problems of adapting books to movies and he touches on adapting video games. However, that’s where he stops and I’d like to add some other adaptations he missed.

Continue reading →