Anime, manga, live-action shows and kaiju, and video games. These are how some people believe is typical Japanese life. No, I don’t think they actually believe Godzilla goes stomping around the city (and if you do, please seek help) but when it comes to how Japanese life is depicted when there are no monsters or mecha running loose Japanese media is about as accurate as US media is to life in the United States Of America. If you think Hawaii Five-O or Magnum PI is accurate to Hawaii or any of the thousands of shows set in New York is accurate…note that often these shows don’t get their own geography correct. Like, I live in Connecticut and whomever was working on Gilmore Girls apparently couldn’t even get a proper map. Granted I know this from a video about it because I’ve watched maybe one episode in full if that but it’s still wrong. And that’s just the live action stuff. Thrown in cartoons, especially the more comedic stuff, and you will be clueless about how we live.

I have two videos to showcase this. Both are produced by The Anime Man (who I should warn you does swear in his videos) but the second guest-stars our old favorite, Gaijin Goombah. These videos will show that learning about Japan through their media alone will not really tell you anything about the country, including anime and manga. Especially anime and manga.

Here’s a link to that “Japan Laifu” playlist he mentioned. He also mentioned that depiction of school life is different, and in another video The Anime Man and Gaijin Goombah went over those mistakes.

And here’s the other crossover Gaijin Goombah mentioned. Of course here’s the link to The Anime Man’s YouTube channel if you want to see more videos like these.

Now, nobody is trying to talk you out of going to Japan. The Anime Man lives there and Gaijin used to live there and still goes back to visit and research. My friend Matt Burkett (you know, Apollo Z Hack and host of kaiju-fan series Monstrosities) has been there a few times recently and loves the place. This is just a warning that if you go you should be prepared to not live the life of your anime favs, and if you live in any city, town, or sometimes even just the state where a US show is produced, or how it works in whatever country you live in and shows set in or near your hometown, you already know that fiction doesn’t always imitate life. Japan is a beautiful country so feel free to go and enjoy yourself.

Just don’t expect to get there by giant robot. I know that’s disappointing.

About ShadowWing Tronix

A would be comic writer looking to organize his living space as well as his thoughts. So I have a blog for each goal. :)

4 responses »

  1. Sean says:

    Read some books about Japan’s history and modern society. Eat some Japanese food. Watch some movies from Japan that focus on Japanese culture such as some of the old Japanese movies from the 1950s that focused on the samurai. Learn about the Ainu, the original Indigenous people of Hokkaido who were living in Japan even before the Japanese ancestors arrived there. The Ainu culture is still alive and well, including their sacred value on the bear. Talk to U.S. military veterans who were stationed in Japan. Or even talk with a Japanese American person (either somebody born in Japan or somebody whose parents or grandparents were born in Japan). Anime and manga can give insights into Japan, but it’s not the only source of knowledge about Japan. People should explore those above options to learn more about Japan. Better yet, go on vacation in Japan or live and work there for a period of time. That will give one the ultimate knowledge on Japan.

    Like

  2. Sean says:

    Also, what exactly were you trying to say about the Gilmore Girls? Please explain your message a little more. I do know that the Gilmore Girls is set in a Litchfield County town. But what is the geographical inaccuracy that you speak of in terms of Gilmore Girls?

    Like

  3. […] of Japanese media who somehow think they now are well verse in Japanese culture and lifestyles. That isn’t the case of course but they like to think so. They’re fans of a romantic view of Japanese culture. […]

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s