
I’m not here to talk about the quality of this or that show. If I mention something in passing it really doesn’t matter when it comes to this topic. And I’ve honestly seen a few variations of this argument used, from “show” to “comic” to “video game”. And it’s one that no matter how it’s being used is very dismissive of children’s entertainment. You know the one.
“It’s just a kids show/comic/video game.”
Whether it refers to an entire medium or a format (like animation) it’s an argument used in the past to limit a production but is now being used to fend off critics…possibly by people who either haven’t seen/read/played it or just likes it for whatever reason and will lay the smackdown on anyone who puts it down. For the sake of my fingers I’ll be sticking with “kids show” as a general reference but if I refer to comics and video games specifically, and I expect to, I will note the difference.
While this “argument” is also used to put very little effort in, thus doing a disservice to kids, saying it doesn’t have to appeal to adults because it’s for kids is also saying they don’t have to put in any effort to be good, which is basically the same insult. Compare cartoons for kids versus cartoons for adults (like Cartoon Network’s “Adult Swim” lineup) and I would say kids shows put more effort into their product than their elder-targeting counterparts. Unless you’re importing from Japan adult toons are more often than not subversive comedies, while kids get action shows (except on Cartoon Network), comedies, and even shows we’d call “slice of life” in anime, from as far back as These Are The Days or Devlin (the latter I saw on reruns on USA’s old Cartoon Express block as a kid and really liked it) to something more recent like Hey Arnold. No, kids shows like My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic or the Netflix She-Ra & The Princesses Of Power don’t have to entertain adults, but the former does and the latter has plenty of detractors. Why is this the case?
Continue reading →
Tell others about the Spotlight:
The “It’s Just A Kids Show” Argument
I’m not here to talk about the quality of this or that show. If I mention something in passing it really doesn’t matter when it comes to this topic. And I’ve honestly seen a few variations of this argument used, from “show” to “comic” to “video game”. And it’s one that no matter how it’s being used is very dismissive of children’s entertainment. You know the one.
“It’s just a kids show/comic/video game.”
Whether it refers to an entire medium or a format (like animation) it’s an argument used in the past to limit a production but is now being used to fend off critics…possibly by people who either haven’t seen/read/played it or just likes it for whatever reason and will lay the smackdown on anyone who puts it down. For the sake of my fingers I’ll be sticking with “kids show” as a general reference but if I refer to comics and video games specifically, and I expect to, I will note the difference.
While this “argument” is also used to put very little effort in, thus doing a disservice to kids, saying it doesn’t have to appeal to adults because it’s for kids is also saying they don’t have to put in any effort to be good, which is basically the same insult. Compare cartoons for kids versus cartoons for adults (like Cartoon Network’s “Adult Swim” lineup) and I would say kids shows put more effort into their product than their elder-targeting counterparts. Unless you’re importing from Japan adult toons are more often than not subversive comedies, while kids get action shows (except on Cartoon Network), comedies, and even shows we’d call “slice of life” in anime, from as far back as These Are The Days or Devlin (the latter I saw on reruns on USA’s old Cartoon Express block as a kid and really liked it) to something more recent like Hey Arnold. No, kids shows like My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic or the Netflix She-Ra & The Princesses Of Power don’t have to entertain adults, but the former does and the latter has plenty of detractors. Why is this the case?
Continue reading →
Tell others about the Spotlight:
Posted by ShadowWing Tronix on November 27, 2018 in Television Spotlight and tagged commentary, Doctor Who, kids show, My Little Pony, She-Ra.
5 Comments