
I must be the only person in my circles who isn’t gaga for Ben Affleck’s Batman.
Admittedly, my problems are, like with Henry Cavill’s Superman–Zack Snyder. Snyder chose the Darker DC of Dan DiDio, being inspired more by The Dark Knight Returns and Watchmen, two graphic novel/miniseries that started the path to where we are today: superhero stories in the main DC universe that aren’t for kids (the age I was when I became a DC fan), too many grimdark “grounded” stories that take the fun out of reading a superhero story (wait until I get an opening for the next installment of my first time Watchmen read series), and then tossing in Snyder’s hatred of bright colors while only using the sun as some visual metaphor for five second before going back to almost black-and-white. (Granted, Hollywood at large seems to share that perspective.) I had to brighten up the image above.
I also don’t like the costume. The ears are too short and, in keeping with Frank Miller’s design, the suit itself is too bulky. Batman is supposed to be a stealthy martial arts acrobat type, not the brutal version we keep getting. The George Clooney outfit was scarier, even counting the “bat-nipples”. It’s not the worst live-action Batman costume; the serials still have that record. I still don’t like it, or his stupid Bat-Tank. Batmobiles aren’t supposed to be tanks! Heavily armored, maybe even lightly armed for emergencies, sure. But NOT #$%#$ TANKS! KNOCK IT OFF!
Could Affleck play a good Batman without Snyder’s influence, the way Cavill could with Superman? Sure, why not? Does he want to? Geeks & Gamers recently posted an excerpt from a Variety interview that seems to say he doesn’t, as he talks about the failings of the Gunnverse, which didn’t hire him back to play Bruce Wayne and probably wouldn’t have once the Matt Reeves/Robert Patterson version was done. (Good luck to Patterson as James Bond. In these days, I don’t expect the “Bond Girl” to be nearly as sexy.)
Ben Affleck spoke to Variety’s Matt Donnelly about his recent film, Animals, which was released on Netflix, as well as his and Matt Damon’s content company, Artists Equity. However, comic book movies had to be mentioned in the interview, and Affleck had no regrets about his time as Batman. “I really liked doing ‘Batman v Superman.’ That was really fun. ‘Justice League’ had a lot of issues, and that wasn’t that much fun, frankly. I was glad that Zack [Snyder] was able to get his vision for how he wanted that movie to be out there. That was rewarding,” Affleck said.
Most of the interview focuses on his new movie, his history, and his production company. I just want to focus on the same section as the G&G contributor, Billy Oduory, did. Affleck, having played a version of the Dark Knight, was of course asked about the recent changing of the guard at DC Studios, with Jeremy Latcham taking over as the man in charge. His comments are worth exploring. I have read the full interview, but it’s easier for me to copy/paste from Oduory’s article.
He also admitted that the dark tone of Snyder’s Justice League caused the DCEU to lose touch with some of the “younger audience.” However, Ben Affleck insisted the tone issue is more a DC problem than a Zack Snyder problem. “It seems to be an ongoing question, and I don’t know the answer: Do you go all the way to a hard-R rating like ‘Joker’? Or do it like Marvel, which does something broad, unless you’re talking about ‘Deadpool & Wolverine?’ he added. According to Affleck, the tone problem goes as far back as Frank Miller’s reinvention of DC Comics.
“There seems to be more tension between ‘Are we doing the grown-up version or the one that’s open to kids?’ There’s a risk of being a feathered fish. It’s something they’re still navigating at DC,” he added. Ben Affleck went on to praise Kevin Feige and the MCU for figuring out their tone.
If any praise can be sent Snyder’s way, it’s that he did keep a consistent tone. Justice League doesn’t count due to Joss Whedon taking over and trying to use Snyder’s footage and give it a lighter tone. Snyder would later get his own cut, probably extended from his original plan given how many parts his cut was, and go back to his darker style. Tim Burton was sent packing from Batman after Batman Returns failed to be kid-friendly, upsetting promotional partners like McDonald’s for the trouble it caused in selling those toys to kids. Kids love superheroes, and way back when, Batman was altered because kids were reading it. That’s why we got Robin in to soften things for the crowd that was really into it without scaring the parents. It’s the rare case of playing to a different audience that worked because it was organic and not snobbish or driven by social nonsense.
Nobody seems to care that Matt Reeves’ take is any less grimdark and “grounded” than Nolan’s. Neither of them was exactly kid-friendly, either. I don’t mean that it’s not made for kids. I’m talking about what we used to call “all-ages”: safe and enjoyable for kids while something that won’t bore adults.
Gunn’s DC Universe, on the other hand, was riddled with tonal issues. How does a movie like James Gunn’s Superman By James Gunn lead into a series like Peacemaker, with the season starting with an orgy, or Lanterns, which ended the season with the most popular Green Lantern shot in the head and a lack of color that would make Snyder thrilled? If you have a shared continuity, there should also be a shared tone. Nobody complains that Burton’s Batman or the Swamp Thing movie that came out around the same time doesn’t have the same tone as the Superman films around the same time because they weren’t treated by the studio as existing in the same continuity. However, the Swamp Thing sequel was given negative points for changing the tone from the first movie, in the same way Halloween III avoided Michael Myers. Meanwhile, Dr. Holland’s actor returned for the sadly forgotten USA Network series, which went back to the first movie in tone, if not story.
“I have to say, Kevin Feige is a kind of genius. I can’t think of any producer in the world who can say, ‘This is what the audience wants,’ and be right, except for him,” the DCEU alum said of the Marvel president.
No, he used to do that. Then Disney got rid of the group that kept him on course with the source material and slowly moved away from what the comic fans wanted, while not getting enough of the casual moviegoer to replace them. Even courting the activists didn’t help because that crowd cares about their social agenda while still not being interested in superhero movies or comic books. They didn’t support the material after they got their way; they just moved on to something else that wasn’t made for them. Speaking of which, the “everything for meeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee” crowd forced changes that have also ostracized anyone who doesn’t share their tastes after whining about “gatekeepers” because the popular thing must be made for them alone, not those stupid geeky people who need to wake up and totally share their “superior” tastes in storytelling. Feige went after the wrong crowd the moment he could, and the MCU has suffered since.
Somebody does need to steer DC Studios and their movies better, and I hope Jeremy Latcham is that guy. He’s from the days of the Marvel committee pushing for comic accuracy and wants to make good superhero stories, hopefully ones that bring families back to enjoy together, or at least cross age-gap lines. We’ll see about that, but the Snyderverse was too bleak and the Gunnverse too unfocused except on what James Gunn wanted. Time will tell if they’re finally on track or the DC universe will continue to fall into obscurity as people reject what it’s become.




