So they did this long story arc about Batman and Catwoman getting married. They explored many angles, made it look like they were the ideal couple, and got people excited to see how this would change the dynamic between the Bat Family. And then they not only tossed it aside but did so by letting the mainstream press spoil the entire thing to tell us we wasted our time getting hyped for this event. That’s a terrible way to do anything!
But it wasn’t the canceling of a Batmarriage that bothers me. It happened on Earth-2 so you know there’s story potential there, but Batman getting married to anyone doesn’t make as much sense to me as the Spider-Marriage or the Supermarriage. (They tried to eliminate the Clark Kent/Lois Lane marriage numerous times as well. They just kept it behind the scenes until the New 52.) But the reason Selina gives for not marrying Bruce, that he supposed needs his misery to properly function as Batman, is pure hogwash! Batman is driven by anger and maybe a bit of brooding. He wants to do what he can to get rid of the same criminal element that took his parents’ lives. But misery isn’t the same as that righteous fury. It’s depression, and depression is more of a stopping force than a driving one. I think he could be happy and still fight crime. Earth-2 proved that. Huntress is originally the daughter of the Earth-2 Bruce and Selina.
Now Selina not wanting to reform from cat burglary and become a crimefighter, for whatever reason, I can believe. But Batman doesn’t need his “misery”. Again, I’m more in favor of an unmarried Batman than I am ending Superman’s marriage, but the silly reason they gave, and the way they ruined (and spoiled) the story arc is something I had to comment on.