
If you haven’t followed my review of this storyline, here are links to reviews of DC’s Star Trek issue #43, issue #44, and issue #45 which came out today, collectively known as “The Return Of The Serpent”. The story is a sequel to the season two episode of the original series “The Apple“. For the record I haven’t seen the episode in a long time but thanks to that wiki link I’m up to speed on what I remember. In the episode the Enterprise comes to the planet Gamma Trianguli VI on a routine mission. Since it aired on TV you can guess it wasn’t as routine as they planned. On the planet they’re attacked by killer fauna and come upon a primitive society who worship Vaal, a computer that controls the planet. While attempting to not interfere events force them to do so. Or did it? The episode features one of the earliest discussions of the Prime Directive, a hands-off rule when it comes to pre-warp planets.
On the one side was Captain Kirk, who didn’t think people should be run by computers. On the other you have Mr. Spock, who figures they were happy and not being tortured or otherwise threatened by their computer god and just leave them be. In the end they end up destroying Vaal. Apparently this ending didn’t sit well with Mike Carlin, who wrote this three issue arc. Therefore he took the opportunity to undo the end of the episode by restoring Vaal and showing what the paradise world had become without they’re cybergod. I don’t have a problem with this. In fact I recommended all three issues as it is a real good story. As far as restoring Vaal, seeing the results of the heroes’ visits to planets can make for a good story. (Not always but we’ll worry about that when we get to those stories.) It’s also possible that other readers may agree with Carlin’s perspective. Star Trek has always been a morality play (not counting the Abrams movies) so the only time the franchise even today messed up was in the execution of those stories, and possibly even the points of view or portrayal of the characters. The comic gets the characters right, but I do want to question how Carlin sets about making his case and why though I see both Kirk and Spock’s point of view on the subject this particular three part story jumps through a few hoops to be right.
Continue reading →
Tell others about the Spotlight: