How is Superman “too iconic”?

Superman

Image via Wikipedia

Dictionary.com defines “iconic” as “of, pertaining to, or characteristic of an icon”. Well, that helps nobody. Let’s see what Merriam Webster Online says about “icon”, because I couldn’t find a separate definition for “iconic” when I went there.

1
: a usually pictorial representation :image
2
[Late Greek eikōn, from Greek] : a conventional religious image typically painted on a small wooden panel and used in the devotions of Eastern Christians
3
: an object of uncritical devotion :idol
4
:emblem, symbol <the house became an icon of 1960’s residential architecture — Paul Goldberger>
5
a: a sign (as a word or graphic symbol) whose form suggests its meaning b: a graphic symbol on a computer display screen that usually suggests the type of object represented or the purpose of an available function

Right, so how does that reply to Superman? I suppose #3 works best, “an object of uncritical devotion”.

Although you could make the case for religious symbol as well. This takes us back to yesterday’s article and the comments of Lee and Didio. Namely this one:

“We’ve made Superman such an iconic figure over the years that we’ve lost some of the character and the ability to tell stories with that character,” said Dan DiDio, co-publisher at DC. “There’s so much continuity that’s been built on this character. We really wanted to get a Superman that is more accessible to the audience.”

Sorry, Dan, the problem wasn’t the continuity. The problem is a running issue at both your place and your “marvelous” competition.

Continue reading →

Today’s Comic> Godzilla: Gangsters & Goliaths #2

Better than one of those RC helecopters.

Godzilla: Gangsters & Goliaths #2

IDW Publishing (July 2011)

WRITER/LETTERER: John Layman
ARTIST: Alberto Ponticelli
COLORIST: Jay Fotos
EDITORS: Bobby Curnow & Chris Ryall
CREATIVE CONSULTANT: Chris Mowry
COVER “A”: James Stoke
COVER “B” (shown) by the regular art team

Continue reading →

Super Failure!

Superman and his alter ego, Clark Kent

Image via Wikipedia

OK, we all knew that the rumors of ending the Supermarriage were going to be true. I even stated as much in my Flashpoint theories, for which I am two out of three. (Actually, if Dick had become Robin instead of resuming his role as Nightwing I would have been surprised, despite the article. I did call Barbara as Batgirl, though.) As I’ve noted in the past, they’ve been trying to undo that for the past 11 years. Now, as my compatriot Snell tweeted,

http://twitter.com/#!/slaymonstrobot/status/93058095533670401

Although Linkara would unknowingly counter with

http://twitter.com/#!/Linkara19/status/93165763376054273

The issue in question comes from this article at Newsarama in which DC’s head fool Dan Didio tries to defend the rebooted Superman. But if you think this is another marriage rant you haven’t read the article. To quote Dark Helmet from Spaceballs “it’s not what you think, it’s actually much worse”.

Continue reading →

Today’s Comic> Doctor Who: A Fairytale Life #4

Just rechecked my comics for this week. Dragon covers are not a trend.

Doctor Who: A Fairytale Life #4

FINAL ISSUE

IDW Publishing (July, 2011)

WRITER: Matthew Sturges
ARTIST: Brian Shearer
COLORIST: Rachelle Rosenberg
LETTERER: Shawn Lee
EDITOR: Denton J. Tipton
COVER “A” (shown): Mark Buckingham (art) & Phil Elliott (colorist)
ALTERNATE COVER: Amy Mebberson

Continue reading →

Retroactivity

TV Land hasn’t had the best of luck when it comes to original programming. There is their awards show, where they honor series of the past. And then there’s stuff like I Pity The Fool, where Mr. T serves as a motivational speaker in the way only Mr. T can. (Seriously find these episodes, this show was awesome! And tell me where you found it because I want a copy!) ALF was also given a talk show. Neither show did very well.

Then came Hot In Cleveland, a sitcom that uses actors and actresses from old shows as stars and guest stars. (I wonder what effect Betty White’s “Snickers” success had for the show? Personally, I think Valerie Bertinelli is still hot, whether she’s in Cleveland or not. ) These people are still talented and there is an audience for the classic sitcom formula. Of course, this could be considered a sitcom version of Sex In The City, and their new show, Happily Divorced, is about a couple who divorces, but still lives together, when the husband realizes he’s gay. So we’re not exactly talking family friendly entertainment here. But my point is that both the format and the performers who would normally be ignored by today’s Hollywood have still “got it” and it’s nice to see them getting work.

Now you may be asking why this is under the “comic spotlight” category and what a couple of sitcoms have to do with comics?

image source: DC Source blog

Starting this week (unless I missed something), DC Comics is beginning a series of one-shots called “Retroactive”. The plan is to bring back famed writers of the 70’s, 80’s, and 90’s, pair them with artists for that period (or a reasonable facsimile if the legend has sadly passed on), and create a story set in DC Universe as it existed back then. Names like Gerry Conway, Dennis O’Neil, Marv Wolfman, and others will return to characters and time periods they helped make famous. Additionally, the comic will include a reprint of a classic tale by that team that may or may not connect to new story. They’re one-shots, not a collective narrative, so you can just grab your favorite hero and period and enjoy the story on its own.

My point? Why stop there?

Continue reading →

Today’s Comic> All-New Batman: The Brave & The Bold #9

Dragons don't play well with their toys.

All-New Batman: The Brave & The Bold #9

DC Comics (September 2011)

WRITER: Sholly Fisch
PENCILER: Rick Burchett
INKER: Dan Davis
COLORIST: Guy Major
LETTERER: Dezi Sienty
ASSISTANT EDITOR: Chynna Clugston Flores
EDITOR: Jim Chadwick
COVER COLORIST: Eltaeb

Continue reading →

Filler article link: Another strong defense of Oracle

I’m finishing up my vacation and I just didn’t get to collect anything newsy for this week. Also, while I had time to draw TWO Jake & Leon strips I didn’t have the urge or opportunity to scan, color, and dialog them. And of the comics this week, only two of them barely had something “Best Scene” worthy, but one requires context in the story and the other was kind of meh. So there’s nothing here this week.

However, I already left The Clutter Reports with nothing but a vacation notice, so I was lucky this popped up in Twitter just moments ago, courtesy of Bleeding Cool. The article linked to is possibly the strongest defense of Barbara as Oracle yet, and I would encourage you to read the whole thing with an open mind. It might not change it if your part of the “Barbara as Batgirl…YAY!” camp, but writer Eric Glover goes into why having Barbara remain as the wheelchair bound Oracle was a good thing for the character and the DC Universe. I may write my own thoughts at some point, but really he hits most of the points I’d make anyway.

The site should return to normal tomorrow, but they’re talking about playing games with everyone’s schedule at work, including mine, so things may get off track for a while in a couple of weeks.